Written by Dr. Roshan Jain (MBBS JJMMC Karnataka, MRCP Psychiatry UK, MMedSc Univ of Nottingham,UK), one of the best psychiatrists in Bangalore.
You may recall the satirical depiction of suicidal threats in an Indian movie called Sholay. Actor Dharmendra was standing on a high-water tank, repeatedly threatening to end his life, by shouting “suicide, suicide”, if his love interest wasn’t realized, or opposed by the actresses’ aunt. One bystander asks another what suicide means, and gets a reply “Jab angrez Marte hai na, to use suicide kehte hain” (when English people die they call it suicide)!
While a desire to seek attention was apparent in the above depiction, that may not always be the case in suicidal behaviour. The fact of the matter is that suicide, and suicidal behaviour is neither a ‘foreign’ phenomena nor is it funny in any way.
The infliction of this deadly violence upon self is a global phenomenon with an epidemic increase in overall rate worldwide. It is one of the top three cause of death amongst youth.
According to WHO, every year almost one million people die from suicide and 20 times more people attempt suicide, which equates to one death every 40 seconds and one attempt every three seconds, on average. So, by the time you read a third of this blog, one more person would have died by suicide.
India has one of the highest suicide rates in the world. An estimated 1.8 lakh people kill themselves every year.
According to a study (by Professor Vikram Patel) published in Lancet, the suicide rate was high in rural India. However, it was ten times greater among well-educated young people from the more prosperous southern states.
Life is a mystery, but death is certain. Uncertainty over the length of our lives is what makes it interesting. But people perceive suicide with shock, dismay and assumptions.
To some suicide may seem like a weakness of mind and to others the only way out of overwhelming circumstances which have a profound bearing on the emotional well-being. For most people, that final act will remain mysterious despite stories from the survivors of suicidal behaviour.
Suicide is the act of taking one’s life on purpose. Suicidal behaviour or deliberate self-harm is any action that could cause a person to die, such as cutting oneself, taking a drug overdose or crashing a car on purpose.
Although a suicidal person wants to escape the unbearable emotional suffering, most people are deeply conflicted about ending their lives. They wish there was an alternative to suicide, but they just can’t see one. Underlying emotional disturbances hinder an individual’s ability to see any alternative. Furthermore, it is compounded by feelings of hopelessness and helplessness. And although they may not ask for help, that doesn’t mean that help isn’t needed. Herein, talking to someone (family, friend, or ideally a trained professional) can bring them out of ambivalence, rapidly.
Are we sensationalising this untimely calamity?
Despite the enormity and frequency of this incident, media reporting remains insensitive and at times irresponsible. The media sensationalises suicide with knee-jerk assumptions about external factors or people responsible. There is no attempt made to understand the personal reasons and circumstances. In short, the media reports the incident, but the story of that precious life taking a tragic turn is missed.
The psychological and social impact of suicide on the family and the society is immeasurable. It can leave a lasting scar on the psyche of the surviving family. We rarely approach this impact in a sensitive manner. What’s worse is a trial by media and the inevitable harassment of the bereaved (notably so in India).
Media houses rarely call on mental health experts, who see and treat people with psychiatric problems and associated suicidal thoughts, to opine on the possible causes or offer education and awareness. The most media houses do is to call a film personality or a writer to opine on what may have happened and how terrible things have become. They don’t make any effort to address the underlying mental health issues and how it could have been dealt with. Distinctively absent on many of those forums is an advisory to seek early professional intervention when a person reports profound pessimistic ideas or suicidal thoughts.
Our bizarre law is finally updated!
The Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) lays down the punishment for attempted suicide. The law categorises all suicide survivors as criminals and subjects them to prosecution and punishment with a maximum of a one-year prison term.
Such an outdated law has contributed to condemnation rather than a compassionate approach to the victims of suicide attempts. Additionally, it has worsened the stigma associated with mental health problems, thereby adding to avoidance or delay in seeking help after a self-injurious act.
Fortunately, with the approval of Mental Healthcare Bill in Lok Sabha on 27 March 2017, there is a paradigm shift in care and treatment of persons with mental illness in India. Pending presidential assent, this new Bill will recognise them as citizens with health rights, including the right to quality mental health care. The bill also effectively decriminalises suicide attempts. The relevant provision of the Mental Healthcare Bill states, “Notwithstanding anything contained in Section 309 of the IPC, any person who tries to commit suicide shall be presumed unless proved otherwise, to have severe stress and shall not be tried and punished under the said Code.
Why inflict lethal violence onto oneself?
Perhaps the rapidity of social change, urbanisation and the potential impact on educated young people – high expectation, burnout and stress.
In the Indian context, relationship problems for women and career or financial difficulties in men seem to be a risk factor.
An estimated 90% of people who attempt or die by suicide have one or more mental health conditions such as depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, as well as drugs and alcohol dependence.
Untreated mental illness significantly raises the risk of suicide.
Identifying risk factors for suicide
Suicide is a complex behaviour where a combination of individual, relational, communal, and societal factors contribute to the risk and vulnerability.
- Family history of suicide
- History of mental disorders, particularly clinical depression
- Untreated mental health problems
- History of traumatic experiences in the formative years such as sexual or physical abuse, parental neglect, rejection and abandonment, etc.
- Previous self-harm or suicidal attempt
- Feelings of hopelessness and helplessness
- Lifestyle causes- alcohol and drug abuse
- Personality feature – impulsive and aggressive tendencies
- Unwillingness to seek help because of the stigma attached to mental health and substance abuse disorders or suicidal thoughts
- Employment status – poor job security, financial problems
- Stressful life events or changes may push a person to the edge
How do we recognise those at risk?
A person who harbours thoughts of ending his/her life may show certain behaviours or symptoms including:
- Settling of affairs and giving away things
- Preoccupation with death and dying
- Isolation and withdrawal from family and friends
- Undue guilt, hopelessness and helplessness
- Engaging in self-injurious behaviour such as cutting self, reckless alcohol or drugs misuse
- Pervasive depressed mood or agitation
- Significantly altered sleep and appetite pattern in context of mood disturbances
- Profound loss of interest in activities or work
- Planning and talking about ways to end their life (such as buying many tablets, pesticides, rope, etc.)
How can we help?
- Education and awareness are the keys. The stigma of mental health problem and widespread misperception of mental illness as being a sign of mental weakness may be one of the biggest barriers to seeking help. Dispel this notion and accept that it’s human to have emotional problems and help-seeking is a sign of strength, not weakness.
- We must take every suicide attempt and threat of suicide seriously. Never dismiss the person as just trying to get attention.
- If you know someone who is having suicidal thoughts, then be calm and where possible get specifics of the plan, means to carry out and intention of doing it. Contact a mental health care provider right away and ‘help them seek help’.
- Survivors of suicide attempt require an empathic and supportive intervention. They must be encouraged to seek professional guidance and counselling to unburden from emotional pain and find an adaptive solution.
- A psychiatrist must see all individuals who are brought to the emergency department or hospitalised after a suicidal act, for a thorough evaluation of mental health and suicidal risks. Further, the specialists must review the patients within one week of discharge to reduce the risk of future attempts.
- Unlike the past, we now have many suicide prevention helplines across the country that can guide individuals and families to appropriate services and experts.
- Psychotherapy (talking therapy) and counselling is an essential part of treatment. It’s an important psychological method for developing insight and awareness of your emotions and feeling.
Also read: Solitude is independence
Suicide is a preventable cause of death. Every effort for the preservation of life is worth it.
I think life has to be greater than all its problems put together. And all problems are solvable provided there is a willing participant. But if the problems seem unbearable then share the burden, talk and let some else do thinking with you, and at times for you.
Remember, suicide doesn’t end the pain; It just passes it on to someone else.
- WHO: Let’s talk about depression – focus on adolescents and young adults
- Handouts on depression, WHO campaign for World Health Day
- Suicide Prevention article on helpguide.org
- What is depression? By Therapist aid
- Suicide: Risk and Protective Factors
About the Author
Dr Roshan Jain is one of the best psychiatrists in Bangalore. He is a UK qualified specialist with extensive experience in psychiatry, addictions, psychotherapy, teaching and motivational work. Based in Bangalore (India), he offers in person-centred mental health evaluation and interventions. He has worked tirelessly in reducing the stigma associated with mental health problems through speaking events and mental health awareness education, workshops & publication.
DocGenie is an online telemedicine platform that provides you quality healthcare from the best doctors in the comfort of your own space. On DocGenie, you will find a select few, highly-qualified doctors, unlike other online platforms with thousands of doctors. So you can be assured of receiving excellent, honest, personalized care from the best professionals.